Skip to content

Atlantic vs Codex

From delegated task to proven pull request.

Codex is OpenAI's coding agent. You or your tools hand it a task, and you review what it returns. Atlantic starts earlier, from your tickets and support desk, and opens the pull request last, after a browser test on video and a second-model review.

  • Browser test on video
  • Second-model review
  • Auto-merge is off by default

Same repository. A different finish line.

Both can write the change. The difference is who picks the problem, how the change is proven before review, and when the pull request opens.

Atlantic

Atlantic reads your backlog, support desk and repository, picks one problem, writes the fix, tests it in a browser, has a second model review the diff and opens the pull request.

  • From tickets to pull requests
  • Evidence on the pull request

Codex

Codex is OpenAI's coding agent. You give it a task in ChatGPT, your editor or the terminal, or assign it an issue in Linear. You review the diff and test results, then commit or open the pull request.

  • Delegated tasks
  • Included in ChatGPT plans
FeatureAtlanticCodex
How work startsThree finders read your backlog, support desk and repository, each working blind. A judge picks one problem.You or your tools hand it a task: assign an issue or mention it in Linear, let a triage rule delegate new issues, or run scheduled tasks on a timer or on Gmail, Slack and GitHub events.
Browser testingBefore the pull request opens, a browser agent drives the change for up to 40 steps on a fresh preview machine, recorded on video.In the desktop app, Codex can drive a built-in browser against your local dev server. OpenAI's docs say browser use is not yet supported in cloud tasks.
Review of the changeA second model reviews the diff. Blockers go back for up to 2 fix cycles before the pull request opens.The /review command checks local changes before you commit. On GitHub, @codex review or an automatic-review setting posts a review on the pull request.
Where it worksWrites only to GitHub today.Code review on GitHub is generally available. OpenAI's GitLab page says GitLab support, including merge request review, is in beta.
How you payA credit is used only when Atlantic opens a pull request. Failed and cancelled runs are free.Included in ChatGPT plans with usage limits. Extra use draws on credits metered per token, and API keys bill at API rates.

What this page says about Codex summarizes the vendor's own public pages, and the table links the page behind every row. If something is out of date, email hello@getatlantic.ai.

When to choose Codex vs Atlantic

Choose Atlantic

  • You want Atlantic to pick the problem from your tickets and support desk.
  • You want a browser test on video and a second-model review before the pull request opens.
  • You want billing tied to pull requests. A credit is used only when Atlantic opens a pull request. Failed and cancelled runs are free.

Choose Codex

  • You want to prompt and steer a coding agent yourself.
  • You want one agent in ChatGPT, your editor and the terminal, on your ChatGPT plan.
  • You work in GitLab. Codex reviews GitLab merge requests in beta, and Atlantic writes only to GitHub today.
Try it on your repo
  • Writes only to GitHub
  • Auto-merge is off by default

Browser test

The change is tested before you review it.

Atlantic boots the branch on a fresh, isolated preview machine and checks its health. A browser agent drives the change for up to 40 steps, recorded on video.

  • Up to 40 browser steps
  • Video attached
A frame from the QA recording of an example run: a browser agent has typed a test name and an example.com address into a profile form.
Example workspace

Where work comes from

Your existing tools become the work queue.

Atlantic watches the backlog (Linear, Jira, GitHub Issues), the support desk (HubSpot today) and the repository. Slack, Sentry and PostHog add evidence.

See integrations
The runs page of the Atlantic app in an example workspace: the newest runs listed with their status and title.
Example workspaceThe values are examples, not customer results.

Review

Atlantic opens the pull request. Your team reviews it.

A second model reviews the diff. Blockers go back through up to 2 fix cycles. Atlantic never pushes to your default branch. Auto-merge stays off unless you turn it on for repositories you name.

  • Up to 2 fix cycles
  • Auto-merge is off by default
The review queue of the Atlantic app in an example workspace: open pull requests listed with the time they were opened.
Example workspace

Questions teams ask before choosing Atlantic

No. Codex is OpenAI's coding agent for tasks you delegate. Atlantic picks the problem itself from your tickets and support desk, and opens the pull request after a browser test and a second-model review.

Three finders read the backlog, the support desk and the repository in parallel, each working blind. A judge links what they found, picks one problem and writes a thesis.

The pull request opens last, with the thesis, evidence, QA verdict and video, and reviewers are requested. Atlantic never pushes to your default branch. Auto-merge stays off unless you turn it on for repositories you name.

No. Atlantic can change only repositories in both your GitHub App install and your own selection. A run can include up to 5 repositories.

Atlantic is priced in pull request credits. Solo is $29 a month for one user and includes 2 credits. Team is $1,499 a month per workspace and includes 60 credits. Scale is $3,499 a month per workspace and includes 200 credits. Enterprise is from $60k a year. A credit is used only when Atlantic opens a pull request. Failed and cancelled runs are free. Extra credits cost $19 each.

Review a pull request instead of chasing a bug.

Atlantic picks the problem from your backlog, support desk and repository, tests the fix in a real browser and opens a pull request for your team to review.